View post

ReiserFS undeletion: the lost, the found, and the ugly

Posted by lucidfox.org at

When mass-renaming video files for Mai-HiME (which I recommend to anime fans out there, unless anything involving magical girls in any way is not your thing; but not the point), I made a mistake in the mv command, which caused all files to be moved to a single destination. I quickly pressed Ctrl-C, but the first four files were lost.

I immediately Googled up an instruction on undeleting files on reiserfs, which (to my dismay) involved unmounting the partition and running reiserfsck --rebuild-tree -S as root. My first thought was: “What a fool I was to choose reiserfs! Surely ext3 can handle undeletion much more gracefully!”

Anyway, I dropped to the root shell, unmounted /home, and in about three hours, it finished. Free space on the partition decreased by about 4 GB, and I found a lot of files in /home/lost+found, many of which turned out to be familiar. I copied files roughly within the size range to a different directory and found three of the four videos (thanks to Nautilus happily displaying thumbnails), but the fourth seemed to be lost.

In retrospect, I should have probably just waited until Monday and asked the guy to whom I lent the DVDs to return them. (And of course, I had no other backup — a lesson to be learned here.) As I remounted the partition and loaded GNOME, minor inconveniences began to pile up.

  • The Tomboy applet failed to load at the first login, but subsequent logins fixed it.
  • The custom GNOME theme (modified Murrine Brave) became corrupted, and I had to restore it from a UFD (where I copied it to bring it to another computer).
  • Thunderbird now just crashed at startup without opening any windows. Luckily, I migrated from POP3 to IMAP Gmail a while ago and moved all my sent mail from the local folders, so just killing the profile was a good option.
  • OpenOffice.org and Gajim preferences were reset.
  • An Eclipse workspace lost all projects and I had to reimport them. Then it turned out that some Java and C++ projects in this workspace now refused to build because reiserfsck restored them at their previous locations, rather than in lost+found! I had to redelete them.
  • Worst and strangest of all, the GTK file dialog now takes a minute to pop up. (Nautilus, mc and the Qt dialog all work fine.) I deleted everything from /home/lost+found and cleaned up the home directory, but the problem still persists…

Was all this worth a partial recovery of deleted files that I could obtain from elsewhere? If it was crucial data, probably… but it wasn’t.

But at least reiserfs has some kind of undeletion — slow, intrusive, problem-prone, but it works. Partially. It turned out ext3 didn’t have even that (while ext2 actually had nicer undeletion).

Maybe I should split the file dump from the home partition and migrate it to ext2…

Comments

getopenid.com/racarr posted at 2008-08-10 17:56:53

GTK file dialog hanging is probably a symptom of tracker, disable it, and kill it until it actually dies (when I had this issue, it only responsed to kill -9), then try again.

lucidfox.org posted at 2008-08-10 18:23:56

I rebooted again, and the problem with the GTK file dialog disappeared… It’s faster than ever!

You must be logged in with OpenID to post comments. If you are a LiveJournal user, simply log in as yourname.livejournal.com.

No OpenID? Get one now!